One Year to the World Cup: Has Thomas Tuchel’s England Backslid Since Southgate? Unpacking the Shift in Football’s Landscape

In a recent friendly match against Senegal, Thomas Tuchel made ten lineup changes, a decision that, while understandable, hasn’t been entirely successful since he took over the reins. Some actions, though, have left fans puzzled.

One such move was the surprising recall of Jordan Henderson, who is set to turn 35 next week. This decision raises eyebrows and questions Tuchel’s confidence in the leadership within his squad, especially given Henderson’s veteran status in training sessions.

Meanwhile, Ajax midfielder’s first start for England in nearly a year came against Andorra, but he failed to make a significant impact. It seems the time has come for this seasoned player to step back from international duties.

Further highlighting age and performance issues, Kyle Walker turned 35 just prior to his 96th England cap against Senegal. In this match, he became the first player over 35 to represent England since Frank Lampard in 2014, but his performance suggested a decline. After a lackluster showing and a reckless booking, he was effectively targeted by the Senegalese side.

This situation raises an interesting question about Tuchel’s view on Trent Alexander-Arnold. With Curtis Jones being selected ahead of him and Walker getting the nod, it’s clear that Tuchel has concerns about Alexander-Arnold’s defensive abilities. However, many believe that Alexander-Arnold brings more to the table than the aging Walker and Jones, who is being utilized out of position.

Reece James, another right-back option for Chelsea, was strangely placed in an unfamiliar left-back position against Andorra, reflecting Tuchel’s tactical dilemmas.

Given the current display of both Henderson and Walker, it’s hard to see them having a role in the upcoming World Cup—a clear indication that time is catching up with them.

In a last-minute attempt to explore options beyond Harry Kane, striker Ivan Toney was brought in from Al-Ahli in the Saudi Pro League. However, he made his appearance only in the dying moments of the match, once again raising questions about Tuchel’s decision-making.